PS John W Robinson died 1941 Liverpool S age 70. ON 1939 register he is alone in Liverpool and gives birthday as 10 Dec 1871. Actually he was a year out. It was 1870, making him 4 months old at 1871 census. His birth reg was in March 1871.
Dave

Correction. His first marriage was to ADA Hanson, not Ann

Hi Dave and many thanks for your help, more than I thought and a mystery cleared.
However I am still confused by the existence of the other William and his wife Nellie and the fact that Nellie died at 38 Heeley Green the home of my grandmother Lily when she married

SAME ADDRESS BUT NOT SAME time. The events were separated by 20 yrs or more.
JUST A COINCIDENCE
Dave