There is a marriage at the parish church (cathedral) 3 Sept 1866 for an Elizabeth BARNSLEY aged 19 to Joseph SHAW and her father is listed as Charles BARNSLEY Cutler.
I have just been directed to this thread by a friend so the response is a little late. Charles Barnsley and Elizabeth Cawkwell were my 2x great grand parents.
Their daughter Elizabeth who married Joseph Shaw was my great grandmother. The Barnsley's were in Sheffield from the 1500s and were cutlers and farmers from that time. They were involved in the foundation of the Hallamshire Cutlers and Charles along with his brother George foundered the firm of George Barnsley and Sons who made tools for leather workers. In a reduced form it is still going and owned by my fourth cousin Colin Barnsley . George andCharles both started their married lives in Allen St. Elizabeth was Charles second wife.
Please do contact me direct if you want more information