GymRatZ Bodybuilding and Fitness Forum


Search For Similar Forums   ·   Return to Website

  First
  Prev
  Reply
  Forum
Next  
Last  
Search this Forum:  
Viewing Page 1 of 1 (Total Posts: 2)


Author Comment    
Matt

Matt@gymratz.co.uk www.equipmentforfitness.co.uk


Oct 27, 05 - 3:51 PM
Creatine & water retention - is Potassium/ Sodium balance and important variable?

Below's a copy of a post I've just put on the urb. I hoping for some informative feedback.

Why do individuals retain water in different areas?

I've read an article in the past about bodybuilding competition prep regarding Potassium and Sodium ratio. Potassium is an electrolyte mineral which means that it has a part in controlling the body's fluid level. Potassium is kept in the cell and is counterbalanced by Sodium. Come competition time better condition can be achieved briefly by reducing sodium and thereby swinging the balance and causing water to be retained within the muscle cell (looking fuller) but not on the outside of the skin (looking dry). Subsequently, it leads me to think that those with a bad diet (high in Sodium) are more likely to retain excess water on the outside when taking Creatine. It would make sense considering most people I've known reporting of "bad" water retention have been quite fat anyway and probably have a diet high in Sodium.

Is the above possible? If so does anyone know of any evidence supporting it?

MATT
---

Exercise Equipment

British Made Gym equipment
Matt

www.equipmentforfitness.co.uk


Oct 28th, 2005 - 11:03 AM
Re: Creatine & water retention - is Potassium/ Sodium balance and important variable?

Interesting links being posted on urb so far about the importance of Potassium/ Sodium balance to maintain healthy fluid levels. Also, seperate links about research with Creatine. Unfortuantely, no research using Potassium/ Sodium intake as a variable when taking Creatine.

Of interest are expensive Carb and Creatine drinks which some individuals favour. I'd always assumed some people experienced more success with these if they hadn't used Creatine Monohydrate correctly. Due to the insulin spike provided by a sugary carb drink, to aid with absorbtion of Creatine, and the extra calories had provided them with greater gains. But perhaps additional minerals have there place. I've compared a couple of the better known products, such as Cell Tech and Maximuscle's 8000gl, which both have additional minerals. However, the Potassium to Sodium ratio is fairly equal in the servings and not close to the recommended ratio. Also, the mg qty's aren't excessive when compared to regular food, so I'd agree with my original assumption as far as they're concerned.

There doesn't appear to be any scientific research using Potassium/ Sodium balance as a variable when using Creatine. Although it must be pointed out that if you've got a healthy balanced diet you're already one step ahead and will experience better progression anyway. If you've tried Creatine and experienced "bad" water retention then you'd be better served correcting your diet rather than trialing another brand, as brand's irrelevant really IMO.

MATT
---

Exercise Equipment & Fitness Equipment

Gym Equipment


  First
  Prev
  Reply
  Forum
Next  
Last  




Get your FREE forum service! 
Blog · Site Rings · Email Forms · Vote Caster  powered by Powered by Bravenet bravenet.com

NO SPAM - FREE VIP offers for subscribers only !
NO SPAM
- FREE Diet & Nutritional advice, Latest news!
NO SPAM - FREE Muscle development and/or Fat Loss course!

First Name:
Last Name:
Email:
Yes
Gym Ratz Home Page Portal Gym Ratz Home Page Portal